STARRED REVIEW
June 2008

Such devoted sisters

By Poppy Adams
Review by
Share this Article:

The leaking, cavernous home in the English countryside where The Sister is set is so cold, so musty and mysterious, you practically feel the damp coming up off the pages. Virginia “Ginny” Stone has lived there her entire life, immersing herself in her work as a lepidopterist (a scientist who studies moths), which is how her family has earned its fame over generations.

As Ginny ages, riddled with arthritis and occasional forgetfulness, so does the house. She closes off first one wing, than another, and sells off most of the valuable furniture until the house is bare. At age 80, Ginny is alone with just her precise daily routine – carefully planned down to the way she meticulously makes her bed in the morning and ensures her many clocks are synchronized – to keep her tethered to sanity.

But then her sister, Vivien, who hasn’t set foot in the house since their mother’s death nearly 50 years ago, turns up to stay. Vivi announces she’s there to look after her older sister, and Ginny has no reason to doubt her. But within hours of her arrival, it becomes clear that Vivi has returned to find something within their sprawling childhood home.

The Sister is a fantastically chilling debut about how love is sometimes more powerful than memory. Author Poppy Adams, a television documentary filmmaker, creates a wholly original character in Ginny, a trusting, simple woman who wants nothing to interfere with her warm childhood memories. In Ginny’s mind, their beautiful, stylish mother and eccentric, brilliant father were the toast of their small village, and Ginny and Vivi enjoyed an idyllic life in the country. So what if their mother drank a touch too much sherry, and their father retreated entirely into his research? So what if Vivi and Ginny were best friends at home, but Vivi ignored her entirely while they were at boarding school? So what if Vivi, unable to have children because of a childhood accident, asks Ginny to have a baby for her, only to turn her back on the child when it’s not what she expected? Vivi’s return brings up long-repressed pain – she insists their family life was pocked with anger, betrayal and violence. Is it Vivi or Ginny who remembers correctly? And is it ultimately more important to remember the past as it was, or to find comfort in how you wish it had been? Like the pervasive dampness in the Stone house, the questions raised in The Sister will linger with you.

Amy Scribner writes from Olympia, Washington.

Trending Reviews

Eunice Wong, Gilli Messer, Nora Dahlia, Teddy Hamilton

Fans of romance audiobooks have grown accustomed to hearing from two narrators as each half of a potential couple. In Pick-Up, Nora Dahlia shakes things up by adding a third voice.

Get the Book

The Sister

The Sister

By Poppy Adams
Knopf
ISBN 9780307268167

Sign Up

Stay on top of new releases: Sign up for our newsletter to receive reading recommendations in your favorite genres.