STARRED REVIEW
November 2006

The mystery of what lies beneath

By David Wiesner
Review by
Share this Article:

2007 Caldecott Medal Winner

Two-time Caldecott Medalist David Wiesner turns from the flying frogs in Tuesday and the cloud factory in Sector 7 to the mysteries of the sea in yet another brilliant, wordless picture book, Flotsam. Like many of the author’s creations, this story begins with an inquisitive child, a boy observing crabs with his magnifying glass along the ocean shore. Without warning, a wave deposits a barnacle-encrusted Brownie-style camera, labeled the Melville Underwater Camera, before the protagonist.

After waiting a seemingly endless hour for the film to be developed, the boy views a set of fantastical underwater photographs: wind-up fish with gears, an octopus family reading to its young by the light of bioluminescent fish, a colony of tiny people residing atop the shells of sea turtles, and stretching starfish-islands. But wait! There’s also a photograph of a girl holding a photograph of a boy. And within that photograph is another boy holding a photograph of a girl. Puzzled, the boy first uses his magnifying glass, and then a microscope, to observe each child’s photograph, ending with a sepia-toned, turn-of-the-20th-century image of a boy his own age. An open-ended conclusion leaves room for any child’s sense of wonder to carry on.

Wiesner proves why he is an award-winning storyteller and illustrator with vivid watercolors that range from vignettes to spectacular full- and double-page panoramic views. Wonderful displays of imagination are evident throughout, as are small touches of humor, such as a photo of overly eager visiting aliens and their unruly children. Older and more astute readers will find many surprises, including a hint to the boy’s discovery in the book’s cover art, a reference to Wiesner’s The Three Pigs on the title page, and a clever imitation of a classic Japanese print, Katsushika Hokusai’s The Great Wave at Kanagawa. Most importantly, Wiesner continues to show children that things aren’t always what they seem. Would the Caldecott committee consider a three-peat?

Angela Leeper is an educational consultant and writer in Wake Forest, North Carolina.

Trending Reviews

Eunice Wong, Gilli Messer, Nora Dahlia, Teddy Hamilton

Fans of romance audiobooks have grown accustomed to hearing from two narrators as each half of a potential couple. In Pick-Up, Nora Dahlia shakes things up by adding a third voice.

Get the Book

Flotsam

Flotsam

By David Wiesner
Clarion
ISBN 9780618194575

Sign Up

Stay on top of new releases: Sign up for our newsletter to receive reading recommendations in your favorite genres.